$299,900

The first thing you will do here is walk out into that lawn and start deciding where everything goes, the garden along the sunny side, the fire pit set well back, the patch under the old shade tree that stays empty because that is the coolest spot on the property… Read More and you are going to want it for yourself. The lot is 0.28 acres, flat and open, and every bit of it comes with the keys. Not many city addresses have that much grass around them. The covered porch is what will slow you down before you reach the door. It stretches deep across the front, set on stone piers laid by hand in 1924, looking out over the whole yard. June evenings belong out there. So does October, with a blanket and a hot drink while the tree lets go of everything at once. It is going to be the first thing you describe when people ask about the place. Inside, the rooms are bright and freshly painted, and the windows do most of the work, pulling light through the front of the house all afternoon. One bedroom is right on the main floor, which is the kind of flexibility you never appreciate until you have it, a desk and a door you can shut on a Monday, a spare room the weekend somebody stays over. Two more are tucked upstairs under the roofline with windows framing rooftops and treetops, quiet enough that a long day actually ends when you climb up there. The basement below runs nearly 23 feet, clean, bright and completely unfinished, which is the good kind of unfinished. Right now it holds the bikes and the holiday bins. In a few years it becomes the workshop, the studio, the practice room, whatever version of yourself you have not gotten around to yet. The space is already bought and paid for. You just grow into it. The upkeep is easy to live with. Natural gas heat takes care of February, and municipal water and sewer mean nothing buried in the yard you ever have to think about. The cabinets were repainted this year and the interior is done, so you move in and simply live in it. Then the city fills in the rest of the year. From June through October the market sets up Saturdays, 8 to 1, at Erie Way Park on Union Street, a 5 minute drive away. Dinner at Oak & Reed on North Street turns into a habit rather than a plan once it is that easy to get to. Thrall Library on Depot Street lends museum passes, so Storm King, DIA Beacon and Bethel Woods cost you a library card and a tank of gas. Outside is just as close. Watts Memorial Park is a little over a mile up Wisner Avenue, and Fancher-Davidge has the pool, the walking trails and a disc golf course on the west side of town. Sunday nights in season the Speedway races on Wisner, near enough that you can decide to go at 6 p.m. and still make it. When you want out of town entirely, the Middletown station on the NJ Transit Port Jervis Line carries you to Hoboken and Penn Station, Route 17 and I-84 are minutes away, and Manhattan sits 70 miles east. A century is a long time for one house to be looked after by the same owners, and it shows the moment you step inside. Nothing here was let go and patched back together later. It was simply kept, one winter at a time, which is why the walls run true and the stonework still sits level. That care is the part you cannot renovate in afterward. It is already here, in the open ground, in the straight lines, in a hundred years of somebody paying attention. All this place needs now is a new name on the deed. Now it is your turn on that porch. Read Less

Listing Courtesy of KW Hudson Valley United.

Listing Snapshot

Days Online

Last Updated

Sep 30, 2026

Property Type

Single Family Residence

Beds

Full Baths

Square Ft.

860

Lot Size

0.28 Acres

Year Built

1924

Property Tax

$4,563

MLS Number

1041109

Additional Details

Appliances & Equipment

Range, Refrigerator

Basement

Unfinished

Building

Built in 1924, Living area: 860, Levels: Two, Construction Materials: Wood Siding

Cooling

Wall/Window Unit(s)

Exterior Features

Patio/Porch Features: Covered, Porch

Floors

Hardwood, Vinyl

Heating

Baseboard, Natural Gas

Interior Features

First Floor Bedroom, First Floor Full Bath, Eat-in Kitchen

Lot

0.2755 acres

Parking

On Street

Sewer

Public Sewer

Taxes

Parcel Number: 330900-009-000-0003-001.000-0000, Annual Amount: $4,562.76, Assessed Value: $16,300, Year: 2025

Utilities

Electricity Connected, Water Source: Public

Find The Perfect Home

'VIP' Listing Search

Whenever a listing hits the market that matches your criteria you will be immediately notified.

Join The List

Mortgage Calculator

Selling price

Down payment

Term (years)

Interest rate (%)

Monthly Payment

256 Cottage Street

'VIP' Listing Search

Schools In The Area

Similar Listings

Find My Dream Home

1. Neighborhoods

2. Home Type

3. Send